Quick links
Current Issue
September, 2023
Vol.56 No.5
eISSN 2765-1614
Quick links
The purpose of peer review for the Journal of Chest Surgery (JCS) includes the followings:
1) To evaluate objectively the science, originality, validity, and potential impact of the submitted paper, AND
2) To provide constructive comments and suggestions to the authors to assist them in improving the quality of the paper.
Two reviewers considered as the most relevant investigators regarding the topic are assigned to review each full-length article. Decisions are based on originality, validity, and potential impact of the material presented. For articles considered as possible candidates for publication, additional positive and constructive guidance through editorial revisions should be made to aid clarity and understanding without altering the meaning. All accepted full-length articles will have undergone a statistical review as well.
Reviewers are requested to recommend the articles that are distinguished by their originality, scientific competence and validity, and articles which will have the greatest clinical, theoretical, and educational impact on the field of thoracic and cardiovascular surgery.
Reviewers are asked to consider the following:
Is the research original?
How important and interesting is the topic of the research?
Does the methods and experimental techniques reach the highest scientific standard?
Are the results reliable and presented clearly?
Are the conclusions justified by the results presented?
Is the discussion relevant and comprehensible?
Are the illustrations and references appropriate and necessary?
Is the paper well organized and with clear English writings?
Will the paper impact the specialty?
Based on the above criteria, reviewers are requested to recommend acceptance, major or minor revision, or rejection, together with the comments that support their decisions. Only papers with the potential to achieve a high priority will be accepted or returned to authors for revision.
The reviewer should keep in mind that his/her imperative is to assist the author in increasing the quality of the paper, and this should be done positively rather than negatively.
Acceptance of a manuscript in the JCS is determined through rigorous peer-reviewing process. After the Editor-in-Chief assign an Associate Editor, the assigned editor sends the manuscript to reviewers for peer-review. The assigned reviewers review the manuscript and their review results are reported to the Editor-in-Chief. Finally, Editor-in-Chief notify review results to the corresponding author(s).
If there is any objection to the review results, corresponding author(s) can appeal within 2 weeks after being notified. Editor-in-Chief has the obligation to notify the results after one more review.
In Seok Jeong, M.D. , Woong-Han Kim, M.D.
, Jong Hyun Baek, M.D.
, Chang-Hyu Choi, M.D.
, Chang Woo Choi, M.D.
, Euy Suk Chung, M.D.
, Jae Seok Jang, M.D.
, Woo Sung Jang, M.D.
, Hanna Jung, M.D.
, Jae-Seung Jung, M.D.
, Pil Je Kang, M.D.
, Dong Jung Kim, M.D.
, Do Wan Kim, M.D.
, Hyoung Soo Kim, M.D.
, Jae Bum Kim, M.D.
, Woo-Shik Kim, M.D.
, Young Sam Kim, M.D.
, Jae Gun Kwak, M.D.
, Haeyoung Lee, M.D.
, Seok In Lee, M.D.
, Jae Woong Lim, M.D.
, Se Jin Oh, M.D.
, Tak-Hyuck Oh, M.D.
, Chun Soo Park, M.D.
, Kyoung Min Ryu, M.D.
, Man-Shik Shim, M.D.
, Joohyung Son, M.D.
, Kuk Hui Son, M.D.
, Seunghwan Song, M.D.
, on behalf of The Korean Society for Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery COVID- ECMO Task Force Team
J Chest Surg 2021; 54(1): 2-8
Sung-Jin Hong, M.D. , Jung-Sun Kim, M.D., Ph.D.
, Geu-Ru Hong, M.D.
J Chest Surg 2021; 54(3): 165-171
Young Kern Kwon, M.D. , Sung Jun Park, M.D.
, Suk Jung Choo, M.D., Ph.D.
, Tae Jin Yun, M.D., Ph.D.
, Jae Won Lee, M.D., Ph.D.
, Joon Bum Kim, M.D., Ph.D.
Korean J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2020; 53(6): 346-352
Suk Kyung Lim, M.D. , Joo Yeon Kim, M.D.
, Young Keun On, M.D., Ph.D.
, Dong Seop Jeong, M.D., Ph.D.
Korean J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2020; 53(5): 270-276
Young Kern Kwon, M.D. , Sung Jun Park, M.D.
, Suk Jung Choo, M.D., Ph.D.
, Tae Jin Yun, M.D., Ph.D.
, Jae Won Lee, M.D., Ph.D.
, Joon Bum Kim, M.D., Ph.D.
Korean J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2020; 53(6): 346-352
Kirun Gopal, M.Ch. , Neethu Krishna, M.H.A.
, Rajesh Jose, M.Ch.
, Surya Sree Chitra Biju, B.Sc.
, Jaya Suriya Pichandi, B.Sc.
, Praveen Kerala Varma, M.Ch.
J Chest Surg 2022; 55(1): 61-68